daen

What does 21 CFR Part 11 require of an audit trail?

An audit trail shows who did what and when. On a validated system it is how the authority comes to trust your data. 21 CFR Part 11 sets few but precise requirements.

Colonnade in golden light under a frieze with an inscription against a blue sky.
The Court House on Nytorv. Photo: dba consult

The short answer

The audit trail must be secure, generated automatically by the system and time-stamped. It must record when a user creates, changes or deletes an electronic record. A change must not hide what was there before. The trail must be kept as long as the data it belongs to, and the authority must be able to review and copy it.

The five requirements, one at a time

Secure

Users must not be able to change the audit trail or switch it off. That also applies to administrators in daily operations.

Generated by the system

The trail must arise automatically, independently of the user. A manual log does not meet the requirement.

Time-stamped

Every event must have a date and time. That requires the system clock to be controlled and synchronised.

The original must remain visible

When a value is changed, both the old and the new value must be shown, together with who changed it.

Retention and access

The trail follows the data for the whole retention period, also after a migration or the retirement of the system.

What is most often missing

The audit trail is switched on, but nobody reviews it. Shared user accounts make it impossible to see who acted. The time on the server is not controlled. And in a migration the data moves, while the trail stays behind in the old system.

Part 11 also requires that the system is validated, that access is limited to authorised users and that records can be retrieved for the whole period. The audit trail only works together with the other controls.

Part 11 and Annex 11

Companies that supply both the United States and Europe must comply with both. The requirements are similar, but Annex 11 emphasises that the audit trail is reviewed regularly. So build the review into your procedures from the start.

When does a consultant make sense?

In a review before an inspection, when a new system is introduced or in a migration, a specialist in data integrity can find the gaps before the authority does. See GxP and compliance.

Contact

Do you need a GxP specialist?

Tell Claudio briefly about the systems and what needs to be reviewed. We cover the rest when we talk.

Claudio Piron, pharma and data centres, dba consult

GxP and compliance

Claudio Piron

53 53 24 28

claudio@dba-consult.dk

Questions and answers

What clients often want to know

Does Part 11 apply to all systems?

Part 11 applies to electronic records that the FDA requires or that are submitted to the FDA. It is decided system by system.

Must the audit trail be reviewed?

Yes, in practice. A trail that nobody looks at finds no errors. The review should follow the risk of the data the trail covers.

What happens to the trail in a migration?

It must move with the data or remain readable for the whole retention period. Plan it before the old system is closed.

Can you find consultants for data integrity?

Yes. dba consult finds consultants for data integrity, audit trails and validation under Part 11 and Annex 11.